How to know if a staffing agency is right for your business
|
Staffing agencies offer a range of strategic partnership advantages that go beyond simply filling open positions. By outsourcing hiring and HR functions, your company can significantly save time and reduce costs — especially when considering the long-term expenses tied to turnover, recruitment advertising, and onboarding inefficiencies.
This creates a streamlined approach to the entire hiring process, presenting only qualified candidates who are vetted and ready to work. Efficiency of this variety allows your teams to focus on core business operations while our experts manage the complexities of talent acquisition and onboarding.
Working with an agency ensures quick response during emergencies, like last-minute call-offs or unexpected workload surges by assigning a trusted advisor ready to provide immediate support. Staffing services also alleviate the administrative burden of managing workers’ compensation claims, payroll, and employment paperwork, keeping both clients and associates protected and compliant while operating as a trusted broker concerned with the best interest of everyone involved.
Prioritizing safety, compliance, and employee satisfaction — creating a win-win environment where businesses stay productive and workers feel supported. Ultimately, a partnership with a group of talent acquisition experts provides an extension of your team, enhancing flexibility, reliability, and long-term workforce stability.
When Does It Make Sense to Work with a Staffing Agency?
Here are six strategic questions businesses should ask themselves to determine if partnering with a staffing agency is the right move for their company, along with their answers:
Six-Point Evaluation Process for Choosing the Right Staffing Agency
1. Define your Scope of Staffing Needs.
Objective: Understand your current and projected staffing requirements.
Key Variables to Assess:
- Number of hires needed (temporary, temp-to-hire, direct hire).
- One location vs. multiple locations—do you need a regional or national partner?
- Skills required (general labor, clerical, skilled trades, healthcare, etc.).
- Volume and urgency—high-volume vs. occasional hiring.
- Internal HR team capacity—what tasks will be outsourced vs. retained?
Tip: Align your need forecast with operational goals for the next 12–18 months.
2. Evaluate Seasonal and Peak-Time Demands.
Objective: Assess the agency’s capability to support you during volume surges.
Key Variables to Assess:
- Do you experience predictable hiring spikes (e.g., holidays, summer, tax season)?
- Can the agency quickly ramp up staff in response to demand?
- Does the agency offer flexible contracts to scale labor up/down?
Tip: Ask for specific examples or case studies of past seasonal support they’ve handled.
3. Confirm Industry Alignment and Specialization.
Objective: Ensure the agency has experience in your industry and roles.
Key Variables to Assess:
- Does the agency specialize in your field (light industrial, clerical, healthcare, etc.)?
- What is their depth of knowledge regarding job requirements and compliance standards?
- Do recruiters understand the labor pool and challenges in your vertical?
Tip: Ask for success stories and client references in your industry.
4. Investigate Screening, Safety, and Compliance Processes.
Objective: Protect your business by ensuring candidates are vetted and safe.
Key Variables to Assess:
- Background checks, drug testing, and E-Verify procedures.
- OSHA safety training and certifications.
- Workers’ compensation coverage and claims management.
- What risk management support does the agency provide?
Tip: Request documentation on their compliance policies and safety records.
5. Assess Service, Communication, and Support Infrastructure.
Objective: Evaluate how well the agency can integrate with your operations.
Key Variables to Assess:
- Point of contact: Will you have a dedicated account manager?
- Response times: How quickly do they fill orders or address concerns?
- Technology integration: Timekeeping, billing, applicant tracking, etc.
- Onboarding and orientation support.
Tip: Schedule a demo or walkthrough of their client service portal or systems.
6. Research Reputation, Longevity, and Financial Stability.
Objective: Choose an agency that is reliable, ethical, and reputable.
Key Variables to Assess:
- How long have they been in business?
- Do they have testimonials, online reviews, or Better Business Bureau ratings?
- Are they involved in professional associations (ASA, SHRM, etc.)?
- Financially sound—do they pay workers on time and maintain proper insurance?
Tip: Call other businesses who use the agency to ask about their experience.
Request talent
Partnering with Crown Staffing offers businesses a unique opportunity to tap into more than 57 years of staffing excellence.
